Saturday, June 6, 2020

WUTHERING HEIGHTS: OVERLY DRAMATIC



The fans of the story WUTHERING HEIGHTS are legion. The book, written by Emily Bronte, remains in print to this day and numerous versions have been filmed, most notable in 1939 starring Laurence Olivier and Merle Oberon as the star crossed lovers Heathcliff and Cathy. What many may not realize is that the story was turned into a TV drama in 1958 for THE DUPONT SHOW OF THE MONTH. Early television was rampant with single dramas and anthology shows as well as series TV. This is one of those.

If you are completely unaware of the story it tells the tale of the Earnshaw family living at Wuthering Heights. The father of the group brings home an orphan he found in the streets and names him Heathcliff. Adored by daughter Cathy and hated by jealous son Hindley, Heathcliff takes care of the stables in return for living with the family. When his father passes away Hindley allows Heathcliff to stay but only as a servant. What he doesn’t know is that Heathcliff and Cathy have fallen in love as time has passed.

One day Heathcliff and Cathy sneak over to the home of the Linton family to spy on them. Injured as she falls from the wall where they were watching, the Lintons take her in and insist she remains until she is well again, sending Heathcliff home. When Cathy does finally return she seems to have lost interest in Heathcliff and now has eyes for Edgar Linton. When a fight breaks out between Heathcliff and Hindley, he leaves Wuthering Heights swearing revenge.

Cathy and Edgar marry and eventually Heathcliff does return, now educated and wealthier than when he left. The stable boy is now a man of means. Unfortunately the same can’t be said of Hindley who has let Wuthering Heights fall into disarray. It isn’t long before he gambles the property away to Heathcliff.

Calling upon the Lintons Heathcliff catches the eye of Edgar’s sister Isabella. Against her brother’s wishes she marries Heathcliff who makes her life hell at Wuthering Heights. Cathy still pines for Heathcliff, eventually wearing herself away to nothing. Before she dies he returns to her and forgives her proclaiming his love.

The story is familiar but bits and pieces were changed to bring it into the format of live television drama. What makes it stand out is the stars of this version, Richard Burton and Rosemary Harris. This was just as Burton’s star was rising making him an actor that TV would not be able to afford later on. Even with these two notable actors the TV play shows the limitations placed on actors more familiar with the stage.

With broadly sweeping displays of emotion that would be needed to reach an audience from the stage they seem a bit over the top here. The same holds true for the loudness of proclamations of love and endearment that bellow rather than whisper. While watching you can imagine how well it would have appeared from an audience point of view rather than as a viewer of TV. But then again at the time it was new, it was fresh and this might have been a high mark at the time.

The DVD offers the show in its entirety including commercials from the time. Sponsored by Dupont (you did catch the title of the series didn’t you?) they are front and center, starting with a rather lengthy commercial about themselves and how there is “better living through chemistry”. I’m not sure how environmentalists today would take that. Other commercials are briefer helping to pay the costs of the series.

The quality of the show is like many from the time period with the blurry look so many of these classics have. But that’s to be expected given the source material. In the end it makes for an interesting look at the story and an interesting look at TV from that time period. If you enjoy both then make sure to pick this one up. 

No comments:

Post a Comment