LADY MACBETH is not to be confused with the Shakespeare play
MACBETH. Instead this film is based on the 1865 novel “Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District” written
by Nikolai Leskov. The film itself judging by reviews is either one you love or
hate. Place me somewhere in between in that confused and bored category.
The story revolves around Katherine (Florence Pugh), a young woman sold
into marriage to a man twice her age named Alexander (Paul Hilton). From their
wedding night forward he may sleep with her but never attempts to consummate
their marriage. Instead he is a controlling tyrant who insists that she disrobe
for him each night before bed and constantly tells her to stay indoors.
When an accident at one of the businesses his father owns calls him
away, Katherine immediately begins to disobey his wishes, walking the grounds
as she chooses. Her only companion is Anna (Naomi Ackie), a servant who obeys
her master but answers to Katherine.
One day Katherine catches the farm hands have hoisted Anna up in a
canvas saying they are trying to weigh her. Katherine forces them to let her
down but is intrigued by what she saw. She tells the ringleader, a new
groomsman named Sebastian (Cosmo Jarvis) to guess her weight upon which he
lifts her in his arms.
Apparently this is all it takes as the two begin a shameful affair
spending most of their nights in bed together. When her father-in-law returns
he attempts to set her straight on how to behave. The end result is his being
poisoned with mushrooms and then Katherine and Sebastian return to the carnal
encounters. As a result of the master’s death Anna loses her ability to speak.
At some point the inevitable return of Alexander is bound to happen.
What transpires from there is something best left for those who make the choice
to watch the film. If you are not among that group then my suggestion would be
to seek out other reviews as someone is bound to make it common knowledge.
For me the film was as detached from emotions as Katherine was when the
film began. Taking place in 1865 it has that feel of a gothic romance novel
without the gothic castle location or the actual romance. Instead that is
replaced with lust and physical contact. Imagine Heathcliff and Catherine
romping around in bed, remove the romance and you’ll get the idea of what I’m
talking about here.
While watching it was easy to note the style being used with little or
no music to interfere with the story. The dialogue is kept to short sentences
when used. The décor is true to the time period with little extras to be found
in the house and the costuming is the same. This might lend itself to realism
but it also tends to add to the boredom as well.
The performances are there with little that is exceptional. Of the
characters it is Pugh as Katherine that has the most to offer here but her
outlook and behavior is so dour that the changes in her personality are
unexceptional. The change from purchased wife with a frigid husband to full on
adulterous tramp is hard to believe. Those that love the film view this as an
attempt at combating the patriarchal system of the time, a liberation of the
female character from her surroundings. I say if you view it that way then
you’re more pretentious than you should be.
I’ve never been fond of movies that attempt to create deep “art”,
normally finding that if the attempt is being made then the odds are the
results will be a grandiose attempt to create something that doesn’t actually
exist. A recent blurb describing another film said something to the effect if
you have to explain what you just watched then the movie wasn’t very good.
Movies like this, where the goal is to make a film with supposed deeper roots
than are on display, fail miserably at what they set out to do. True art in
film more often comes without the intent of it being so.
Perhaps there are other out there who will enjoy the film and I say
good for you. As for me it was difficult to stay awake and watch. Compound that
with the early scenes of Katherine being told to disrobe by her husband,
watching an actress in a role that requires her to do so and then considering
the furor over Harvey Weinstein and his behavior and it just leaves you with a
bad feeling.
Click here to order.